Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Independence and Health Care

Once again, my comment was too long for the box, so I made a new post.

Funny enough, a few days ago I quickly checked facebook to see some friends' news. After reading some things and logging out I turned to my wife and said "I HATE politics."

I must correct myself. A lot of good things have been done through politics. I dislike the bad things people do in the name of politics.

I had just read another scathing rant between several parties about the ACA.  Yes, Benjamin, people tend to go black and white on this and call each other evil if they think differently. It is getting out of hand. I listened to a BYU forum the other day by a guy named Mark DeMoss, a prominent evangelical, consultant for Christian-based groups, and past political aide. He also started and later ended the Civility Project to encourage civility in the political sphere. Part of his forum talked about how Christians should be civil as Christ would be, even when we disagree. It is a good listen  (http://speeches.byu.edu/?act=viewitem&id=2013).

HEALTH CARE: I was cleaning some oil stains on carpet this morning and thought about how what I was doing was similar to health care. Some people believe steam cleaning is the only way to go. However, steam often releases the glue holding the carpet down, leaving bubbles. Some people believe the buffer and pad method is the only way to go (I worked for Heaven's Best in high school). Both work toward one goal, but using different means. Both have flaws, both have positives. Not one is perfect.

We have to understand that health care is a huge and complex dilemma and not one thing will fix it. Some politicians tend to go to one solution to fix a whole problem because they have limited time and resources. This happens in any camp or political group. I could site many programs, but the one that comes to mind is No Child Left Behind. In all probability, it has left a lot of kids behind. You cannot fix all of America's diverse education problems or accommodate all of America's diverse students with one bill or program. This is my main complaint about the ACA. I wholeheartedly agree that health care needs to be addressed. However, ramming a program through the government is probably not the best solution.

The individual mandate? Could be good, might be bad. I'm not a fan of insurance either or being required to buy it. I can see both sides on this. I am not required to have a car, but modern society is a bit difficult without one, or without a phone, computer, and other things. Does our future society necessitate to some degree buying insurance to guarantee that life goes on without major interruptions? Possibly. Is there another way? Maybe. Tax breaks for those that do buy it? That has been suggested. I don't have an answer, I'm just saying that things like this probably won't solve all the problems.

Money is a huge issue for health care. How do we fund it? Does the government ever ask that? Ben, you mentioned helping people and society out by chipping in. I agree, it should be a voluntary thing.   What I am afraid of is how creating affordable health care programs will affect spending. I've tried to research Massachusetts as the test case, but sometimes it's hard to wade through the info. Spending for their health care did double in a few years and they had to have grants from the feds. Just a little scary to think what could happen with money escalating.  However, any other solution would probably require money too, so no win for money.

Socialized medicine: one major problem I have heard time and time over again is the line at the doctor when people get sick. If health care is completely covered by taxing the people or whatever they do in England, Japan, and other countries, then that means a mass of people seeing few doctors. Some people die waiting.

INDEPENDENCE: A lovely topic. Truly. But I probably won't get into the tear-jerking accounts of military or other patriotic stories.

One thing to remember is that the colonies were not fighting for independence from government, but from a tyrannical government. They believed the King and England's government was overstepping bounds and controlling the colonies too much. No taxation without representation comes to mind. They wanted a government that would allow them some rights as Americans. That is also one reason religious people came to America.

Some people may see the ACA as a federal government overstepping its bounds. One of the great debates when our country was in diapers was federal government vs. state government. Many representatives were afraid of a government similar to England's where a ruling elite would control things like commerce, industry, etc. Is this happening now?


For a later discussion, what do you think about America being involved militarily overseas? This is a large issue I've been thinking about the last few years. James, I would love to hear your take on this. Soldiers sometimes have a unique perspective on this and I am a curious individual.

Sunday, July 1, 2012

240

First off, thanks, all, for a great campout.  It was fantastic to see you all again, and to relive the glory days, and look for a hole we didn't find.  It may not compare in magnitude, but in Sunday School today we discussed Alma 17 in which Alma meets Ammon, Aaron, Omner, and Himni after some years apart doing their several works, and I was reminded of our little gathering.  I appreciated being able to discuss all that we discussed, and I learned that my body is not so fond of sleeping bags as it once was.

With the current uprising concerning the individual mandate, I got to thinking about such things as I read many a heated commentary on Facebook about how this is both the greatest moment in recent US history and the first step down a deep slope to absolute constitutional obliteration, to exaggerate but slightly.  One FB friend, in particular, seemed incensed that we had chosen oppression over independence, socialism over democracy.

I think I can guess where the Libertarians in the room stand on the subject, and I think most Republicans and Democrats respectively (or disrespectfully) know where they are supposed to stand.  What I find most discouraging about the debate in general is that people seem to be so ready to cast stones (labeled generally as cold hard facts) at others in an attempt to "convince" one another of the evil of their respective ways without pausing a moment to consider the validity of various idealogical differences.  It would seem a presumptuous thing for me to assert my correctness over yours so categorically, particularly when there is very little chance that I bother to gather facts from sources with which I am unlikely to agree.

What I've been thinking about over the last few days is independence vs. interdependence.  Particularly as we approach Independence Day this week, we consider the ideal of independence to be one of the great virtues we posses and revere as a nation.  I think it's good for a country to be independent of other countries, and for countries which believe in independence to grant the right to others.  What struck me in my Facebook friend's post, however, was how he bemoaned the end of independence, not from a foreign hand, but from our own government.

Was the idea ever to be independent of government?  Or independent of one another?  Isn't there a difference between not being oppressed and being dependent?  I think about all of the ways I am dependent on my government, and in most cases I'm really quite happy to be so.  It actually makes me glad that other motorists are required to carry liability insurance.  I don't mind so much paying taxes on gasoline, considering that doing so means I have good roads on which to drive my cars.  Municipal taxes to support a deterrent for people to break in to my house?  I'll get behind that.

If the colonies had wanted complete independence from not only England, but from each other, could they have achieved it?  Could they have fought the revolution melee style, every colony for itself, and won?  Where would we be if they had?

Independence does not equate with progress.  A nation of independents would have no borders, no public services, no laws, no common rights, no recourse for wrongdoing.  It would consist entirely of farmers working all day, every day, to feed their own families, and he who hath the best shot hath the most land.  He who hath the strongest back hath the most food.  And nobody hath an iPhone.

Isn't it our interdependence that makes us great?  The fact that I invented a better irrigation system so that you could grow more crops means that we both get fed and fewer of us have to do the farming.

It's remarkable to me to look back through history and see how yesterday's liberal ideas are today's conservative ones.  I think both are important, if only to ensure that we evaluate our progress honestly.  How many times, though, have programs or policies been vehemently decried because they were "evil", and yet have so much to do with providing the liberties we enjoy today.  There are certainly lines that should not be crossed, and we should always be on guard to protect them, but it's so easy to take a position on principle without drilling down to figure out what the actual principle is.

I wonder if, at the advent of public education, a similar fight ensued.  What have we gained by giving everybody a better chance at being literate?  Is your kid's education my problem?  I think so.  Even a heartless corporation needs employees who can read and write and communicate with other humans.  Public education is just good economic policy.  Is your kid's health my problem?  I tend to believe that the same arguments apply.

From my point of view, I don't think that the requirement to either buy health insurance or pay a fine at tax time is bad, and I'm not particularly fond of health insurance in the first place.  As evolved humans, we seem to agree that it is right to take care of a sick person.  Unfortunately, modern medicine is expensive.  I agree that it's somewhat uncomfortable to be required to pay for somebody else's care, that it would be better if we all just did it voluntarily.  It's funny that everybody seems to agree that everybody should have access to healthcare, and that the "right" thing is for everybody to pitch in so that can happen; it's just a matter of having to or not.  An attitude shift during tax time would seem to me to solve the disagreement completely.

In short (finally), I think I don't have much problem with the idea or spirit of the individual mandate.  If the nation gets more healthy, I'm happy to pitch in.  The actual mechanics and implementation of the system are likely to be flawed and imperfect, because they will be designed and enforced by politicians, but I think it's right to get stepping in that direction.

What do you all think about it?

Oh, and this is, I believe, the 240th post on our blog.
-Benjamin

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Resurrecting Saddam

Benjamin--they killed Saddam.  We can't get him back.

Funny thing, I was just going to assert myself as well and declare a bunch of things, when I saw that I had a new email. Sure enough, James beat me to it. I was even going to say do your own lunch. That's what I get for going to help with the baby.  j/k

Three things I would like addressed:

1st: I think we need our own firewood. I can bring this, if we can fit it in the truck.

2nd: Utensils, paper plates? I can bring these for the group as well. (unless we do mess kits, but I lost mine ages ago)

3rd: Is there room to tie my bike on top of our junk? I kind of want to be semi-mobile for my own reasons. Maybe I should have made a deal about bringing 1 and 2 if I could bring 3.










Here's the Plan:

OK, here we go.  I hereby assert a bunch of stuff which can be treated as the defaults for what we are doing, if we decide to do something else or change it then so be it.

Looks like Cedar mountain is where we are leaning, so lets make it duck creek campground.  Apparently some reservations are available, I will place one in the next 24 hours if I have not heard otherwise from anybody.  I imagine that with 14 impaired the demand will be lower, but it won't hurt to make sure.

I recently got a couple dutch ovens, and have the food already to make that classic standby of dutch oven potatoes and chicken.  I have gotten pretty good at some more advanced recipes and can make them instead if anybody would prefer, but I think that this will work fine.  This means I will take care of dinner completely.

I will also be happy to make my dutch ovens available for use for breakfast. We will have a dutch oven omelet, or a mountain man breakfast, or whatever you want to call it.  The assignments for this meal are as follow:
  • Abe - 18 eggs
  • Ben - 1 red pepper, 1 green bell pepper, 2 medium onions
  • Ked - 1 lb sausage
  • Nate - 1 lb bacon
  • James - 1 bag frozen hash browns, cooking supplies, oil, salt/pepper, etc.
For lunch the next day, it will be bring your own lunch.  Sounds like there is a high probability of us doing something or being somewhere at that time, so it should probably be something portable.

Everything I have seen calls for great weather, so I plan on sleeping under the stars and will not be bringing a tent.  I will bring a large cooler and some ice, and I will bring a water cooler (2 or 3 gallons, I think there is water at this campground for refilling).

We will meet at Abe's house at 5:00 for an immediate departure.  I will have my truck available and can fit all of us if necessary, although the back seat won't be as nice for somebody (except Ben who probably won;t notice the difference).  I don't anticipate it being too uncomfortable for anybody in just the 45 minute drive.  I can probably fit all of our gear in the bed as long as most of you are minimalistic campers.

Anything I missed?  Feel free to chime in below and make changes to this plan, and we can get a final version of this plan in another post tomorrow night.

The Plan

We don't need a dictatorship.  We just need something other than a straight democracy.  Appointing a person "in charge" would be a better way to go for this type of thing.

 Results of the poll are mostly in and it seems with time constraints and things that Cedar Mountain would be a good option. It is close and fairly easy to navigate.  As far as activities we can go cave hunting or a myriad of other things, hikes etc. The road opens as 5 pm on Friday so that would be a departure time for all that can make it by then.  It is open all day on Saturday for the return.  As for food I think group meals would be relatively easy.  I don't have much camp gear, but I would be happy to by some eggs, bacon and pancake mix for Saturday and Hot dogs and buns for Friday night, I even have roasting sticks I can bring if we don't want to rough out our own sticks.

Someone else can volunteer for lunch on Saturday or we can do our own thing if nobody wants to claim responsibility I can buy stuff I just wouldn't be much for deciding what to eat.

As for campsites either TE-AH or Duck Creek would serve I think.  They are first come first serve so it would just depend on which hasn't been taken.

Let me know what you think.

Abe

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

The Time is Far Spent

So, what's the plan?

As far as meals go, I think that depends on where we're going.  If we go somewhere more established campground-y I motion for some everybody meals.  If we are going to have to pack things in too far or lack much by the way of cooking facilities, we may be better off with lighter backpacking-style fare.

I understand Nate may get here late-ish Friday; if that's the case, does that influence our location decision?  Do we want to go somewhere he can find us when he gets here, or should we still plan to all go en masse?

So many questions.  This is why dictatorships are easier.  Didn't we have a dictator once?

Friday, June 15, 2012

THE VOTES ARE IN!

It appears it was a 3 to 2 vote to go to Disneyland!

I am only here to ask more questions, something Abe will have to deal with.  You have to ask a lot of questions before you can get the right answers.

Food.

Separate meals? Together?